Baxters American Grille

Chris Snider a month ago

My husband and I went to Baxter’s to celebrate our anniversary recently. We really need to go there more often!!! Our entrees were excellently prepared, and we had a lovely bottle of wine as well. Our server, Destiny, was outstanding, and that would be an understatement! She was personable, professional, and there when needed, not hovering… when we go back, I definitely will request her! Also! We thought the price of our dinner and wine was very reasonable!

Shaeghlyn LeRoy 2 months ago

Went on a night they had jazz music on the patio. Food was good, music was good, the patio was nice and clean (as were the bathrooms). The umbrellas were so low everyone has to duck to walk out from under them. We were there a few hours, so maybe that was part of it, but we had 4 different servers tending to our table. Some communication issues were had, but resolved.

Shivika Singal 3 months ago

We went to Baxter’s to celebrate graduation and Father’s Day. While the Food and service were great I’ve never understood why the restaurant take reservations and why the servers ask if we are there to celebrate something special when they don’t really acknowledge or make the event special that way. Hence, I am just giving it a four star. We ordered a lot of food a lot of cocktails everything tasted pretty decent and overall it was a good experience but nothing to write home about. Also, I do want to call out that we did not have any steaks we stuck with the pastas and flatbreads and a bunch of appetisers which all tasted great. We also had a vegetarian in our party and it was good that we were able to find some nice vegetarian options. Highly recommend the strawberry spinach salad which was a summer special.

Daniel Demetro 4 months ago

I fell in love with Baxter's this evening. The food was amazing, the Brussels sprouts in particular but when I say the service was above and beyond, I mean it. I noticed one of the waitress' earrings and commented that I liked them. She pointed me to another waitress named Paige who'd actually made them. I told Paige I liked her work and wondered if I could purchase a set for my wife. She refused money, and gave me a pair for free. I don't even have the words for how much I appreciate it. Thank you so much!

Jennifer Calef 11 months ago

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ We came here for a girls’ dinner to celebrate a friend, and it was perfect from start to finish! The atmosphere was fun and welcoming — just what we were hoping for. The food was absolutely fantastic, but what really made the night stand out was our server, Lily. She was amazing — so personable and attentive! She kept our drinks full, gave us great recommendations, and made sure everything was just right. You can tell she genuinely cares about her guests and enjoys what she does. Lily truly made our dinner feel special — thank you for such a great experience!